DTG vs Screen Printing: Which Is Cheaper for Your Order Size?
Screen printing gets cheaper past roughly 24–50 shirts with a 1–3 color logo. Under that, go digital. Real prices, a side-by-side comparison and picks.
By The MerchCamel team5 min read

By the MerchCamel team · Updated November 2026. MerchCamel is a Cincinnati print shop that runs screen printing, DTF and embroidery in-house for teams, schools, families and companies.
For a handful of shirts with a full-color design, a digital print is cheaper because there's nothing to set up. Once you pass roughly 24 to 50 shirts with a one- to three-color logo, screen printing wins, and it gets cheaper at every price break after that.
One honest note before we start: we don't run DTG. For small, colorful orders we use DTF, which does the same job on more kinds of fabric. Here's how all three compare, so you know what you're getting wherever you order.
Quick take
Under about 24 shirts, or a design with lots of colors: digital printing (DTG or DTF) usually costs less, because there are no screens to make.
24 to 50+ shirts with a 1–3 color logo: screen printing is the cheapest per shirt and lasts the longest.
At MerchCamel the price on the product page already includes a one-location print, and we pick the method that holds up best for your design.
What's the difference between DTG, DTF and screen printing?
Screen printing pushes ink through a mesh stencil (the "screen") onto the shirt. Each ink color needs its own screen. Making screens takes time, so the first shirt is the expensive one and the hundredth is cheap.
DTG (direct-to-garment) works like a big inkjet printer. It sprays ink straight into the fabric. There's no setup, so one shirt costs about the same to print as fifty. It looks best on light, 100% cotton shirts.
DTF (direct-to-film) prints your design onto a clear film, coats it with a glue powder, then heat-presses it onto the shirt. Like DTG, there's no setup. Unlike DTG, it works on cotton, polyester and blends, light or dark.
DTG vs screen printing vs DTF, side by side
| Screen printing | DTG | DTF | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheapest at | About 24–50+ shirts | 1–24 shirts | 1–24 shirts |
| Best for | Logos and text in 1–4 solid colors | Photos and gradients on light cotton | Photos, gradients and fine detail on almost anything |
| Fabrics | Cotton, blends, polyester | Mostly 100% cotton | Cotton, polyester, blends |
| Dark shirts | Great | Needs a pretreatment spray first | Great |
| How it feels | Soft, becomes part of the shirt | Very soft on light shirts | A smooth layer on top; you'll notice it on big solid areas |
| How long it lasts | The life of the shirt | Can fade after many washes | Holds up well washed cold, inside out |
| Setup | One screen per color | None | None |
| At MerchCamel | Yes | No | Yes |
Where's the crossover between DTG and screen printing?
Screen printing has a fixed cost up front: making a screen for every color. On 12 shirts, that cost is split 12 ways. On 100 shirts, it's split 100 ways and nearly disappears.
Think of it like a Cincinnati chili order. Every ink color you add is like going from a 3-way to a 4-way: one more thing to set up before anyone eats.
Digital printing has no setup, but each shirt takes the same time and ink no matter how many you order. So it starts cheaper and stays flat. For a one- or two-color logo, the lines usually cross somewhere between 24 and 50 shirts. Every extra ink color pushes that point higher, because each color adds another screen.
You can see the quantity effect in our own pricing. Here's the Gildan 5000 with a one-location print:
| Shirts | Price per shirt | You save |
|---|---|---|
| 1–10 | $13.14 | — |
| 11–23 | $12.48 | 5% |
| 24–47 | $11.86 | 9.75% |
| 48–99 | $11.27 | 14.26% |
| 100+ | $10.70 | 18.55% |
Every size and color of the same design counts toward that total, so 40 shirts split across six sizes and two colors still get the 24–47 price.
Why we use DTF instead of DTG
DTG is great on a white cotton tee. But a lot of group orders aren't white cotton tees.
Teams want polyester performance shirts like the Sport-Tek ST350. Schools want dark colors. Companies want blends that don't wrinkle. DTF prints full color on all of those without a pretreatment step, so we picked the method that covers more of what you actually order.
Camel's pick
Family reunion, 30+ shirts, one- or two-color design: screen printing. It's the cheapest per shirt and will still look good at next year's reunion.
Team of 12 with a full-color mascot: DTF. No setup cost on a small order, and every color in the mascot comes through.
Office of 60 with a two-color logo: screen printing on the BELLA+CANVAS 3001. It feels like a shirt from a store.
Five shirts for a birthday trip with a photo on them: DTF.
You don't have to make this call yourself. Tell us your design and how many you need, and we'll print it the way that holds up best. Want the full breakdown of the two methods we run? Read DTF vs screen printing.
FAQ
Is DTG or screen printing more durable? Screen printing. The ink bonds with the fabric and usually lasts as long as the shirt does. DTG can fade after many washes, especially on dark shirts.
Can you screen print just one shirt? You can, but the setup makes it the wrong tool. For one shirt we use DTF. We have no minimums, so ordering one is fine.
Do you offer DTG printing? No. We run screen printing, DTF and embroidery. DTF covers the same small, full-color orders as DTG, on more fabrics.
What file should I send? A PNG with a transparent background, an SVG or a PDF works best. A JPG or a screenshot is fine to send; we'll tell you if it will print well.
How long does it take? Most orders ship about 10 business days after you approve the art. Need it sooner? Ask for a quote and tell us your date.
What's the difference between DTG and DTF? DTG sprays ink straight into the shirt, so it looks best on light cotton. DTF prints onto a film that's heat-pressed on, so it also works on polyester, blends and dark colors.
What is the longest-lasting t-shirt print? Screen printing. A screen print usually lasts as long as the shirt. On polos and hats, embroidery lasts even longer, because there's no ink to fade.
Get a custom quote. A real person sends a mockup and price, usually the same day. Start here.
- Print methods
- DTG
- Screen printing
- DTF